All-Fair Toys and Games
AKA: Alderman, Fairchild Company
All-Fair Incorporated
Churchville, New York
1926 – 1952

All-Fair Toys and Games branched off of Alderman-Fairchild Company of Rochester, NY in 1926 and moved to Churchville, New York. At the time, Herman Fisher was promoted to vice president of the new company. In 1930, Mr. Fisher made an unsuccessful attempt to buy the All-Fair Toy Company. Still wanting to start his own toy company, Mr. Fisher moved to East Aurora, New York and created Fisher-Price with Irving Price and Helen Schelle.

All-Fair Toys command a high value because of their rarity, bright colors and movement, their association with Herman Fisher and their similarity to early Fisher-Price Toys. Many collectors of vintage Fisher-Price will add All-Fair toys to their collections.

The Wonderful Wizard of Oz board game All-Fair- Logo All-Fair- Cowboy-#285 c. 1928 9.25”L x 11”H x 3.75”W Toy $450 - $600 All-Fair- Cowboy-#285-Box 1928 10"L x 11"H x 4"W $68 - $80 All-Fair- Growly-Grouch-#230 c. 1931 8”L x 8”H x 3.5”W $450 - $600 All-Fair- Smarty-Dog #277 c. 1926 8”L x 8”H x 3.5”W $450 - $600 All-Fair- Terrier 1933 10"L x 8.9"H x 4"W $600 - $800 All-Fair- Doxie-with-Tail c. 1928 12”L x 6”H x 3”W $600 - $800 All-Fair- Happy-Tabby-#283 c. 1932 10.25”L x 9.5”H x 4”W $450 - $600 All-Fair - Billy-Goat-#280 c. 1930 9.5”L x 10.5”H x 3.5”W $450 - $600 All-Fair- Dolly-Duck-#227 c. 1928 Rectangular hat. 8”L x 10”H x 2.75”W $300 - $400 All-Fair- Wally Duck #225 c. 1926 Rectangular hat 8”L x 10”H x 2.75”W $450 - $600 All-Fair- Cardboard-Duck 12”L x 8”H x 3.1”W $120 - $160 Box $30 - $40 All-Fair- Gabby-Goose Gabby Goose shown with logo and without All-Fair- Gabby-Goose-#282 c. 1930 7.75”L x 6.75”H x 3”W $150 - $200 All-Fair- Gabby-Goose-Box Box $225 - $300 All-Fair- Mr.-Quack-Duck-#275 c. 1926 Round hat. 8”L x 10”H x 2.75”W $300 - $400 All-Fair- Mrs.-Quack-Duck-#276 c. 1926 Round hat. 8”L x 10”H x 2.75”W $300 - $400 All-Fair-Mrs-Quack-Photo 1934 Photo All-Fair- Rooster-#450 c. 1933 10.5”L x 9.5”H x 3”W $240 - $320 All-Fair- Maude-and-Sammy-#201 c. 1930 6”L x 8.75”H x 3.75”W $570 - $760 All-Fair- Maudie-Kicking-Donkey-#201 c. 1928 10”L x 6”H x 3.5”W $105 - $140 All-Fair- Big-Maude-Kicking-Donkey-#215 c. 1928 14”L x 10”H x 3.5”W $240 - $320 All-Fair- Jack-the-Kicking-Donkey c. 1926 8.75”L x 6”H x 3.75”W $105 - $140 All-Fair- Kicking-Donkey c. 1926 8.5”L x 6”H x 4”W $90 - $120 All-Fair- Hauler-Hank c. 1926 11.5”L x 6.5”H x 3.5”W $360 - $480 All-Fair- Hauler-Hank-#222 c. 1930 11.5”L x 6.5”H x 3.5”W $900 - $1200 All-Fair- Hauler-Hank-#222 1930 10"L x 7"H x 3.5"W $900 - $1200 All-Fair- Hank-Hauler-#222 c. 1930 11"L x 5.15"H x .5"W $900 - $1200 All-Fair-Hauler-Hank-#222 12"L x 6.5"H x 3.6"W All-Fair- Bouncing-Bunny c. 1929 (Estimate) 6”L x 8.75”H x 3.75”W $300 - $400 All-Fair- Humpty-Hump-#281 c. 1926 9.5”L x 10”H x 4”W $525 - $700 All-Fair- Humpty-Hump-#281 c. 1931 10”H x 9.5”L x 4”W $525 - $700 All-Fair- Humpty-Hump-Advertising-Toy est. 1930 9.5”L x 10”H x 4”W $600 - $800 All-Fair- A.B.C.-Giraffe-#279 c. 1930 7”L x 13.5”H x 4”W $600 - $800 All-Fair- Bruno-Circus-Bear-#204 c. 1927 5”L x 8.25”H x 3.75”W $600 - $800 All-Fair-Bruno-The-Bear c. 1927 3.14"L x 8"H X 5.25"W $600 - $800 All-Fair- World’s-Fair-Johnny-Bull-Frog 9.75”L x 7.75”H x 4.75”W $525 - $700 All-Fair- Johnny-Bull-Frog-#284 c. 1932 9.75”L x 7.75”H x 4.75”W $450 - $600 All-Fair- Air-Derby $75 - $100 All-Fair- Tiddledy-Winks $12 - $16 All-Fair- Texas-Rangers $30 - $40 All-Fair- Pop-&-Plop-Shooting-Game $45 - $60 All-Fair-Our-Gang-Tipple-Topple-Game c. 1930 13"L x 5.5"W $225 - $300 All-Fair- Pin-The-Tail-on-the-Donkey $16 - $20 All-Fair- TUTOOM Journey to the Treasures of Pharaoh $30 - $40/Board only All-Fair- Football-Game $30 - $40 All-Fair- Junior-Auto-Race-Game SPE DEM $45 - $60 All-Fair- Zoom $30 - $40 All-Fair- Magazine Trade ad from Playthings c. 1931 All-Fair- Tip-the-Bell-Toy-Game Est. 1929 12"L x 12"H x 1.5"W $90 - $120 All-Fair- The-Game-of-INDIA 1948